Ice Cream Pies and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches
Ice Cream Pies
Ice cream pies are hand-packed in a crumbled cookie crust with a layer of fudge, our homemade ice cream, and a variety of toppings. Pie orders require 48 hours notice, and may be ordered online, in-store or by calling our store.
A limited supply of stock pies are in our freezer daily – please stop by for availability!
Traditional
Cookies & Cream Pie
Cookies & Cream ice cream hand-packed into a fudge lined chocolate cookie crust and topped with crushed Oreos, chocolate drizzle, and whipped cream dollops
Peanut Butter Oreo Pie
PB Cup ice cream in a fudge lined chocolate cookie crust and finished with chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, a dusting of crushed Oreos, and drizzles of chocolate & peanut butter sauces
Vegan Ice Cream Pie
Choose one of our delicious vegan ice cream flavors* to be hand-packed into an Oreo crust, and finished with crushed Oreos and a chocolate drizzle
*call the store for information on current vegan offerings
Green Monster Pie
Green Monster ice cream in a fudge lined chocolate cookie crust and finished with crushed Oreos and a chocolate drizzle
Cookie Monster Pie
Cookie Monster ice cream hand-packed into a fudge lined chocolate crust and topped with a chocolate drizzle, crushed Oreos & Chips Ahoy chocolate chip cookies, and finished with whipped cream dollops
Cookie Dough Pie
Cookie dough ice cream in a fudge lined chocolate cookie crust topped with fudge drizzle, cookie dough bits, mini chocolate chips and whipped cream dollops
Mud Pie
Our homemade Coffee Oreo ice cream hand-packed in a fudge lined chocolate cookie crust and finished with a chocolate drizzle, dusting of crushed Oreos, and whipped cream dollops
S’Mores Pie
Our decadent chocolate ice cream hand-packed into a fudge lined graham cracker crust and topped with marshmallow and chocolate drizzle, dark chocolate mini chips, graham crumbles, and whipped cream dollops
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Pie
Chocolate Chip ice cream in a fudge lined gluten free chocolate cookie crust and finished with mini chocolate chips, whipped cream dollops, and a chocolate drizzle
Custom
Custom Pies
Seasonal Pies
Check back soon!
Ice Cream Pies and Cookie Sandwiches
At West Side Creamery, our ice cream pies and ice cream cookie sandwiches take your dessert experience up a notch, combining the creamy delight of our unique flavors with the warm comfort of baked treats.
Imagine a rich pie filled with your favorite ice cream, set in a crumbled cookie crust that melts in your mouth, or enjoy our scrumptious cookies, baked just right and loaded with our handmade delicious ice cream. Every bite is a wonderful mix of textures and flavors, crafted to evoke joy and fond memories.
Whether you’re celebrating a special moment or simply treating yourself on a sunny day, our ice cream pies and ice cream cookie sandwiches are the ideal indulgence to share with friends or savor alone. Experience the magic of these special creations that are sure to thrill your taste buds with every slice and every cookie.
